That part is almost always broken. Almost as if it's junkyard procedure to look under there, just like they always look under the rear seat for some reason. And since they never bother to remove the two screws forward of the armrest, they break the panel.
I shared similar thoughts with Martin in reaction to seeing this at a yard near me. The person who did this is a straight-up asshole and lazy dumbfuck because all they took was the center stack trim panel.
While I don't absolutely need another cluster surround, getting one in better shape than mine (broken and re-glued upper screw holes and rear fasteners, but outward facing surfaces look fine) is worth the trouble considering I have pristine extras of the black center stack and driver's door trim pieces.
Also, way to ruin a part that can fetch as much as $350. This dumbfuck didn't even have the intelligence to get it for himself to resell.