I was team woodgrain until the view of the cluster bezel. Now I'm not so sure.
I think it creates a bright point in the interior, similar to the chrome door releases. The wood sort of blends in.
The silver looks odd against the tan itself.
Does it though? I think it works. Think of Lincoln interiors of the early 2000s; they were full of silver trim regardless of interior color.
What about painting to match the door cards?
Nah. That would be very similar to the faux suede overlay I started out with. Too much of the same (color).
Or the wooden bezel as Matt suggested.
The difficult part would be finding appropriate donor wood in that size.