I wouldn't say it's hated, but forums are no longer the high-traffic destinations they once were. For a niche with continually dwindling interest like MN12s, rather than say, a whole car brand where you'd want to differentiate by different model subforums, the way that XenForo added support for new posts as a default display option makes sense. In a smaller community, it's better for people to be presented with all the new content rather than have to seek it out, especially if the top-listed subforums are low-traffic ones like Club Related.
What didn't make sense was VS's "Recommended for you" implementation which achieved neither objective of displaying a forum list nor the latest posts, and was some combination of duct tape and BS that clearly makes no sense on ultra low traffic forums like the old place.